Fayol vs Mintzberg, Who Is Right?

Fayol vs Mintzberg, who is right? The theoretical models of management inaugurateed by Henri Fayol and Henry Mintzberg respectively, consume throw and striking differences in how they explain the changing whizz of management and leadership(Brooks, 2009). To argue whether the image displayed by Fayol is superior to that of Mintzberg I will examine the strengths and weaknesses of the differing models and compare, as well as with the opinions of other theorists. This will allow me to conclude which image is prime(prenominal) and in what senses the descriptions of management established by Mintzberg are ineffective. In this show I will argue that while it is clear that the concepts of Fayol halt been largely superseded by advanced(a) descriptive views such as those of Mintzberg and Kotter, he laid out the foundations so to handle (remove this) that allowed modern thinkers to develop their theories in greater detail. This means that it isnt such a matter of who is right, rather the models of roles and functions exhibited by Fayol and Mintzberg interlink and complement each other, and are in many senses still different, displayed by the fact Fayols model is prescriptive and Mintzbergs descriptive.

Henri Fayol in 1916 published Administration Industrielle et Generale which set out the primary(prenominal) elements of management (Gray, 1984 cited in Fells, 2000), these were to forecast and plan, organise, coordinate, command and control (Pugh and Hickson, 2003). He also outlines fourteen principles of management including discipline, authority and responsibility, equity and fi rst (adapted from Fayol, 1949 cited in Brook! s, 2009). These principles were ground on the experience of Fayol as a Managing Director as well as positions in everyday management (Pugh and Hickson, 2003). This gave him a wide knowledge base on which to develop and present his managerial model. Fayols work is distinctly classicist in nature, which was based on a sharp perspective to management. charm it could be argued...If you want to get a full essay, mold it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper