A Critique of William J. Bennett's "Against Gay Marriage"

William J. Bennett, a great spokesman for American conservatives, has powerfully argued as the denomination indicates in his article ?Against Gay Marriage.? One does not pitch to agree with Bennett to appreciate the strength and goodness of his mind. Still, although he raises thoughtful objections to same-sex mating, his argument overall reads more like an outline, lacking specifics and good opinions, referring to only champion organized, careful study, and committing a number of consistent fallacies which muddy and weaken his argument.

For example, in his opening, Bennett makes a very unafraid assertion--if not an outright exaggeration-- when he says that recognizing same-sex marriage ?would be the some radical step ever taken in the deconstruction of society?s most important institution? (288). The lecturer may wonder if any studies or expert opinions cost to support Bennett?s view. Of course, Bennett is respected for his personal opinions, but wasn?t the question about improving?In the following paragraph, Bennett, lacking(p) to squelch the movement toward redefinition of marriage, cites the rather outlandish example of devil brothers: ?On what principled grounds could the advocates of same-sex marriage oppose the marriage of two consenting brothers?? By citing two homosexual brothers, Bennett commits the ? drinking straw man? fallacy.



That is, he reasons from an exceptional case that defies logic and, formerly recognized, does little for his argument. Who else has ever seen such an extreme example? By the way, is this a real pair of brothers, or are they simply made up and cited for the sake of argument? I untrusting the latter as the two brothers remain nameless--and place-less, as well.

It appears that one logical fallacy breeds another, as in the very next paragraph, Bennett commits what strikes me as a glaring over-generalization. Referring to the traditional view of marriage, he asserts, ?Nor is this view arbitrary...

If you want to get a full essay, tell apart it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper